Urban colonization is driven by a mixture of evolutionarily conserved and labile traits

Urbanization is a fast and dramatic transformation of habitat that generally forces native fauna into novel ecological challenges. The biological prerequisites necessary to establish in urban areas have been widely studied, but the macroevolutionary characteristics of traits that allow urban colonization remain poorly understood. Urban colonization might be facilitated by traits that are evolutionarily conserved and which lead to a diversity of closely related species. Alternatively, urban colonization might be associated with labile traits that frequently arise and are lost. In a large data set from passerine birds, we find that urban colonization has a signal of highly labile traits, despite many traits associated with colonization being highly conserved. Urban colonization is associated with traits that allow faster speciation than non-urban-colonizing counterparts, and more frequently transition to non-urban trait states than in the opposite direction. Overall, the traits that facilitate urban colonization are a mix of highly conserved and labile traits and appear to provide an evolutionarily successful strategy.