Phenotypic structure and genetic correlates of adolescent psychiatric symptomatology in versus out of autism

Objective: Mental health challenges are highly prevalent in autism, but the degree to which they are similar in experience and etiology to the general population remains unclear. This study's objective was characterization of phenotypic and genetic architectures of psychiatric symptomatology in versus out-of-autism. Methods: Psychiatric symptoms were evaluated using the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) in 22,152 children (8-15 years): 11,111 autistic children with verbal abilities from SPARK and 11,041 non-autistic children from ABCD. The CBCL's canonical, population-wide factor structure and genetic associations were compared between cohorts. In parallel, exploratory factor analysis was conducted in SPARK, with resulting dimensions associated with key clinical phenotypes (cognitive ability, co-occurring neuropsychiatric diagnoses), polygenic scores (PGS) for psychiatric disorders, and de novo burden in autism-associated genes. Results: Confirmatory factor analysis supported the canonical structure in ABCD but not in SPARK. Psychiatric PGS associations with canonical CBCL subscales were weaker in SPARK than in ABCD, with the ADHD PGS association to Attention problems lower in SPARK ({beta}=0.05 [CI: 0.04,0.06] than in ABCD ({beta}=0.17 [0.13,0.21]). SPARK exploratory factor analysis replicated canonical internalizing factors while revealing other structural departures, including a distinct Developmental Delays factor and dispersion of social problems across multiple factors. The Developmental Delays factor had the strongest associations with de novo burden and lower cognitive ability but was weakly associated with psychiatric PGS. In contrast, common genetic variation explained larger proportions of variances in somatic and inattentive factors and had stronger PGS associations. Conclusions: Correlation structures and genetic architectures of psychiatric symptoms differed in autism compared to the broader population, emphasizing the need for autism-specific approaches in assessment and treatment.