U-shaped effects of humidity and the impact of misspecified weather-transmission relationships in epidemic models

Understanding the relationship between weather conditions and infectious disease transmission has important public health implications; nevertheless, the functional form of this relationship often remains poorly understood. Humidity has previously been suggested to have a U-shaped effect on the transmission of respiratory pathogens, with optimal transmission occurring at both low and high levels. Here, to assess the impact of this functional form and of its potential misspecification, we first simulate transmission rates based on the U-shaped relationship and then test whether an exponential function accurately estimates these rates across a range of climates. We further use a transmission model to simulate case count data for a range of hypothetical pathogens, comparing outbreak dynamics under the U-shaped forcing function to those under the best-fit exponential approximation. In our simulations, the model fit for the exponential function is climate-dependent, performing best in very dry and very humid environments. In locations where specific humidity values centre around the vertex of the U-shaped function, the exponential model underestimates the amplitude and frequency of incidence peaks. These findings demonstrate the potential consequences of assuming an incorrect functional form for weather-infectious disease relationships and highlight the need for more careful consideration of this functional form in modelling practice.