Endogenous and environmentally modulated leaf shape plasticity in Boquila trifoliolata: how good is the evidence for mimicry?

Reports that the South American climbing vine Boquila trifoliolata modifies its leaf shape to mimic leaves of its host plant have raised considerable attention. Boquila leaf development was proposed to reflect visual inputs perceived in an unknown manner. However, the very existence of Boquila leaf shape mimicry remains inconclusive, since the reported observations are open to alternative explanations. We performed an initial quantitative characterization of leaf shape variability in glasshouse-cultured clonal Boquila plants grown without close host contact, and attempted to reproduce the leaf shape mimicry phenomenon under controlled culture conditions using live olive (Olea europaea) plants, artificial (decoy) olive or artificial ivy plants as supports. While we found leaves of variable shape (including those resembling ivy leaves) both in plants grown without host contact and in those climbing on live or decoy hosts, we did not observe any link between leaf shape and host presence or character. Instead, the leaf shape appears to be affected by environmental conditions including the season. Although our study was limited to a single Boquila genotype and an ecologically unrealistic host selection, our observations suggest that the alleged mimicry might originate from unintentional misinterpretation of intrinsic discontinuous leaf shape plasticity in field observations.