Reevaluating Maturity and Spawning Potential of Atlantic Bluefin Tuna in the Slope Sea

The management of Atlantic bluefin tuna (Thunnus thynnus) is currently defined by a long-standing life-history paradox: a stark divergence in maturation schedules between the Eastern and Western stocks. While the Mediterranean contingent matures at approximately 104 cm straight fork length (SFL; age 3-5), the western stock has long been characterized as a late-maturing, at [~]190 cm SFL (age 8+), and as late as age 15.8, based on size-at-catch data in the presumed exclusive spawning areas of the Gulf of Mexico. This discrepancy defies maturity states confirmed by endocrine hormones as well as established life-history principles that link metabolic energetics to reproductive biology. To resolve this critical issue in stock assessment, we present a sensitivity analysis based on the first histological evidence of spawning- capable individuals from 42 bluefin females (97-244 cm curved fork length or [~]95- 236 cm SFL) sampled in June 2025 within the Slope Sea, Northwest Atlantic. This historically overlooked, temperate spawning ground must be recognized and past estimates of stock productivity reevaluated. Our data provide a conservative estimate of length-at-50% maturity, L50 for females at 123.3 cm SFL, effectively reconciling the reproductive parameters of the two stocks based on histology. Our findings align established bluefin tuna metabolic and evolutionary symmetries in life history, irrespective of management boundaries. Incorporating this previously unrecognized spawning group (i.e., smaller, younger fish) calls for a substantial upward revision of Western spawning stock biomass (SSB). This biomass represents an intrinsic biological buffer that could contribute to the Atlantic bluefins adaptation and resilience. Appreciating demographic diversity is critical to accurately diagnosing stock vulnerability, ensuring that management frameworks protect long-term population stability in the face of climate-driven oceanographic shifts and ongoing exploitation pressure.