Estimating gender disparities in surgical sterilization uptake in India in 2019-20 and cost savings from equity achievement

Background: Qualitative studies have noted that the burden of family planning disproportionately falls on women in India. Our primary objective was to quantify the gender disparity in the uptake of surgical sterilizations. Our secondary objectives were to calculate the costs of tubectomies and vasectomies in India and to estimate the savings of scaling up vasectomy rates. Methods: We conducted a retrospective analysis using data on the total number of tubectomies and vasectomies performed, postoperative failure, and postoperative mortality due to these procedures, obtained from the Health Management Information System (HMIS) for 2019-20. We calculated the vasectomy (tubectomy) operative rates per 10,000 men (women) of reproductive age (15-49 years). The women-to-men ratio of these rates is used as a proxy for sex-based disparities in uptake. State-specific procedure costs and compensation for failures and postoperative deaths at public hospitals were extracted and aggregated from government data and research studies. To estimate the financial benefit of scaling up vasectomies, the cost of increasing the vasectomy rate to 50% of the total sterilization rate was calculated. All costs were adjusted for inflation to 2022 and presented in United States Dollars (USD). Findings: In 2019-20, the national tubectomy rate was 96.5, the vasectomy rate was 1.4, and the resulting women-to-men rate ratio was 67.5. The cost per tubectomy procedure was 3.5 times that of vasectomy (89.1 USD vs. 25.3 USD). Keeping the overall operative rate constant, the net savings from scaling up vasectomies to at least 50% of total operations (replacing excess tubectomies) range from 62,193,487 to 75,355,777 USD. Interpretation: Our pan-India analysis confirms that the use of surgical family planning methods is disproportionately higher among women. Scaling up vasectomies has finacial benefits and can improve gender equity. Funding: None.