Differential causative effects of germline pathogenic variants in MUTYH and PALB2 in a patient with colorectal polyposis and breast cancer

Purpose Patients carrying Germline Pathogenic Variants (GPVs) in multiple cancer susceptibility genes (CSGs) can be described within the context of Multi-locus Inherited Neoplasia Allele Syndrome (MINAS). The role of each GPV is typically interpreted based on clinical phenotypes. Here, we used tumor sequencing, particularly mutational signatures, to investigate the contribution of GPVs in MUTYH and PALB2 to colorectal polyposis and breast cancer in a single patient at a molecular level. Methods We analyzed tumor sequencing data, including mutational signatures and genomic scars, of a breast tumor and a colorectal polyp from a patient with biallelic GPVs in MUTYH and a heterozygous GPV in PALB2. Results The colorectal polyp showed a dominant contribution of MUTYH-associated Base Excision Repair deficiency (BERd) mutational signatures, with no evidence of Homologous Recombination Repair Deficiency (HRD). In contrast, the breast tumor showed both MUTYH-driven BERd and HRD-associated signatures, including SBS3, ID6 and an elevated HRD score, despite the absence of a detectable second hit in PALB2. These findings suggest a differential contribution from the CSGs, with MUTYH contributing to both lesions and PALB2 contributing specifically to the breast tumor. The observed pattern does not align with the additive or synergistic models described in MINAS. Conclusions Our study provides evidence that mutational signatures can elucidate the contribution of multiple CSGs to tumorigenesis within a single patient. These findings extend current interpretations of MINAS beyond additive or synergistic phenotypes, which may help to better understand tumor etiology, with potential clinical implications, including eligibility for targeted therapies.