Integrating social-ecological dimensions of fisheries non-compliance in a stochastic framework

Non-compliance with regulations threatens the sustainability of fisheries worldwide. Understanding the interconnected feedbacks of this complex social-ecological problem is key for sustainability but rarely integrated into fisheries management. We provide an adaptive stochastic modelling framework that integrates economic, social behavior, and ecological aspects of the Chilean kelp fishery, which plays a critical economic and ecological role in coastal social-ecological ecosystem. High levels of non-compliance is threatening sustainability, fishers well-being, and ecosystem health. Our model considers inherent environmental uncertainties and enables the assessment of different harvesting and compliance scenarios and the role of market-based economic incentives in reducing non-compliance. Results show that, unlike the sustainability obtained under an idealized full-compliance scenario, under dynamic compliance the social, economic, and ecological feedbacks leads to system collapse. Importantly, price premiums can promote compliance and sustainability, but the probability of collapse, albeit small, still exist. Our generalizable stochastic modeling framework evidenced that accounting for inherent uncertainty in natural resource management is key to designing interventions for sustainability.