Comparison of Extraction Methods for the Quantification of Phytohormones from Tomato Fruits and Leaves by LC-MS/MS

Accurate, simultaneous, and efficient quantification of chemically diverse phytohormone species is a critical task towards understanding the complex system of phytohormone signaling pathways. Quantification of phytohormones with the commonly used technique liquid chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry is susceptible to the influence of non-phytohormone components present in the sample, a phenomenon referred to as matrix effect. To reduce matrix effect, some phytohormone quantification methods include additional steps of cleanup of crude extracts. However, to what extent additional purification steps provide increased accuracy compared to simpler, less laborious methods is seldomly evaluated. We evaluated three previously described phytohormone extraction methods, two of which include solid-phase extraction and one that does not, in their ability to minimize matrix effect and generate accurate estimates of phytohormone species spanning six classifications, from fruit and leaf tissue of Solanum lycopersicum cv. Micro-Tom (tomato). Our results show that, while the methods that included solid phase extraction occasionally outperformed each other regarding matrix effect and/or recovery efficiency for broad range of phytohormones, they rarely outperformed the simpler single-phase extraction method. Short AbstractAccurate, simultaneous quantification of chemically diverse phytohormones by LC-MS/MS is frequently confounded by matrix effects, leading to the incorporation of additional purification steps. We systematically compared three published extraction protocols with or without solid-phase extraction in tomato tissues across six hormone classes. Solid-phase methods occasionally improved matrix suppression or recovery, but did not consistently outperform the single-phase approach, questioning the added value of extra cleanup steps, particularly when high-throughput is desired, as in the case of systems biology interrogations.