Early life thermal plasticity and adaptive divergence among populations of Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus)

Climate warming alters the thermal environment experienced by ectotherms, whose physiological performance and fitness are constrained by temperature. Early life stages are often the temperature-sensitive phases of the life cycle, with potential consequences for population persistence, particularly in freshwater stenotherms such as the Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus). The persistence of populations will partly depend on the adaptive potential of critical life stages to environmental changes. In this study, we used a common garden approach to compare the response and phenotypic plasticity of four charr populations to warmer conditions. These populations inhabit thermally contrasted lakes and differ in origin (native/introduced) and management history. We reared embryos at either an optimal (5{degrees}C) temperature for larval development or a warmer but realistic (8.5 {degrees}C) temperature. We tested adaptive divergence among populations in four traits (survival, incubation duration, body length and yolk sac volume), using Qst - Fst comparisons. We report negative effects of temperature on body size, survival and earlier hatching. Thermal reaction norms differed among populations, indicating adaptive divergence. Contrary to expectations, populations originating from warmer environments did not consistently exhibit higher trait values under elevated temperatures. In contrast, the unmanaged and colder high-altitude population exhibited higher survival rates and lower yolk reserves for a given size under heat stress than the other populations. Our results suggested that evolutionary trajectories specific to each population are shaped by factors related to the populations history, including introductions, demographic fluctuations and long-term repopulation practices, which can jointly influence the potential for adaptation to heat stress.