No preference for performance: Host plant preference, offspring performance and host plant distribution in the butterfly Aricia artaxerxes

The connection between female host plant preference and offspring performance is important for understanding how relationships between plants and phytophagous insects have evolved. According to the preference-performance hypothesis, female insects should evolve to oviposit on host plants on which offspring performance is the highest. Here, we examined the preference-performance hypothesis in the northern brown argus (Aricia artaxerxes) butterfly in the province of Uppland, Sweden, by comparing female host plant preference and larval growth between the host plant species wood cranesbill (Geranium sylvaticum) and bloody cranesbill (G. sanguineum). We also investigated if host plant preference in A. artaxerxes was related to the geographic distribution of A. artaxerxes and its host plants in the province Uppland. We found that the A. artaxerxes females, contrary to the preference-performance hypothesis, preferred ovipositing on G. sylvaticum, even though larvae feeding on G. sylvaticum were slightly smaller than those feeding on G. sanguineum. Since G. sylvaticum is more abundant and probably more utilized than G. sanguineum in Uppland, an explanation for this negative preference-performance connection may be that there are advantages associated with utilizing a more common host plant species, even though larvae feeding on this plant show reduced growth rates. Overall, the results show that factors other than offspring performance, such as geographic distribution, may influence female host plant preference in A. artaxerxes.