Minimal Influence of Material Surface Properties on Initial Bacterial Attachment to Built Environment Surfaces

Biofilms in the built environment (BE) can harbor pathogens and have been linked with negative health outcomes, particularly in hospital environments. The formation of biofilms requires bacterial cell attachment on surfaces, such as hospital plumbing, which can have varying properties, including roughness, wettability, chemistry, and charge. Despite the importance of bacterial attachment to surfaces, the role of multiple surface properties has been minimally investigated. Using seven materials with differing surface characteristics, this work considers the initial attachment of Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Bacillus subtilis, and Staphylococcus aureus to investigate the impact of several surface characteristics. Initial attachment was evaluated using column experiments and compared to batch experiments in which bacterial growth on coupons was monitored. The attachment of all bacterial species was not influenced by material surface properties, with similar attachment seen across materials tested. Bacterial cell envelope morphology affected attachment, with gram-negative species displaying greater attachment than gram-positive species. Attachment efficiency () was found to be a good predictor of bacterial attachment, with greater sensitivity than batch tests. Establishment of commensal communities should be the focus for limiting pathogens in the BE, as engineering surfaces to reduce microbial attachment appears to offer limited benefit.