Microbial community-level features linked to divergent carbon flows during early litter decomposition in a constant environment

During plant litter decomposition in soils, carbon has two general fates: return to the atmosphere via microbial respiration or transport into soil where long-term storage may occur. Discovering microbial community features that drive carbon fate from litter decomposition may improve modeling and management of soil carbon. This concept assumes there are features (or underlying processes) that are widespread among disparate communities, and therefore amenable to modeling. We tested this assumption using an epidemiological approach in which two contrasting patterns of carbon flow in laboratory microcosms were delineated as functional states and diverse microbial communities representing each state were compared to discover shared features linked to carbon fate. Microbial communities from 206 soil samples from the southwestern United States were inoculated on plant litter in microcosms, and carbon flow was measured as cumulative carbon dioxide (CO2) and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) after 44 days. Carbon flow varied widely among the microcosms, with a 2-fold range in cumulative CO2 efflux and a 5-fold range in DOC quantity. Bacteria, not fungi, were the strongest drivers of DOC variation. The most significant community-level feature linked to DOC abundance was bacterial richness--the same feature linked to carbon fate in human-gut microbiome studies. This proof-of-principle study under controlled conditions suggests common features driving carbon flow in disparate microbial communities can be identified, motivating further exploration of underlying mechanisms that may influence carbon fate in natural ecosystems.