Comparative assessment of genomic, phenomic, and metabolomic prediction models in biparental grapevine breeding populations
Borrelli, C.; Delannoy, L.; Chepca, H.; Calcaterra, M.; Chedid, E.; Arnold, G.; Dumas, V.; Baltenweck, R.; Maia-Grondard, A.; Hugueney, P.; Merdinoglu, D.; Duchene, E.; Avia, K.
Show abstract
Accelerating grapevine breeding for disease resistance and climate adaptation remains constrained by long generation cycles. We benchmarked genomic (SNP), phenomic (NIRS), and metabolomic (untargeted LC-MS) prediction for 24 agronomic traits in a biparental population phenotyped over three years. Seven statistical frameworks and four tissue x timepoint combinations (wood; vineyard leaves at budbreak and flowering; greenhouse leaves at flowering) were evaluated, together with feature-wise BLUPs across samples. Cross-year and cross-population analyses with two additional populations assessed temporal robustness and transferability. Genomic prediction was most accurate (up to r = 0.83), metabolomic prediction was intermediate (up to r = 0.59), and phenomic prediction was lowest (up to r = 0.39) despite its lower acquisition cost. Metabolite features were more heritable than NIR wavelengths, for which most unexplained variation remained residual under the fitted model. Multi-omics integration produced limited overall gains. These results support genomic selection as the primary approach, with metabolomic or phenomic screening considered only for traits and sampling designs that show reproducible predictive signal.
Matching journals
The top 7 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.
Similar papers in this journal
- Genetic architecture of inter-specific and -generic grass hybrids by network analysis on multi-omics data 92%
- Validation of a novel associative transcriptomics pipeline in Brassica oleracea: Identifying candidates for vernalisation response 92%
- Integrative Multi-Omics Analysis Reveals Stress-Specific Molecular Architectures in Soybean under Drought and Rust Infection 92%
Similar papers in this journal
- Integrating genomics and multi-platform metabolomics enables metabolite QTL detection in breeding-relevant apple germplasm 94%
- In a nutshell: pistachio genome and kernel development 91%
- The Genetic Basis of Microbiome Recruitment in Grapevine and its Association with Fermentative and Pathogenic Taxa 91%
Similar papers in this journal
- Integrative multi-environmental genomic prediction in apple 93%
- Prediction of fruit texture with training population optimization for efficient genomic selection in apple 92%
- Exploration of a European-centered strawberry diversity panel provides markers and candidate genes for the control of fruit quality traits 92%
Similar papers in this journal
"Similar papers" are the closest papers from that journal in the model's embedding space. They show what the match is built on, but the ranking comes mostly from a classifier over the whole training set, not from these examples alone.