Back

We need to feel that the Government value our lives: Examining Irish women's experience of cervical screening services

McGregor, R.; Foley, S.

2024-08-23 sexual and reproductive health
10.1101/2024.08.23.24312417
Show abstract

Cervical cancer is one of the top three cancers diagnosed in women globally. When women have access to a testing programme, abnormal cells can be detected to prevent the development of cancer. Research to date indicates that social and cultural barriers are the top two barriers in accessing cervical screening. In Ireland there may be a lack of trust in the National Cervical Screening programme due to previous mishandling of tests, and media coverage of the impacts of inaccurate screening results in Ireland. To understand impact of the health scandal on womens trust in cervical screening in Ireland, nine Irish women ages between 25-65 were interviewed. Data was thematically analysed using a feminist perspective to centre the womens voices in making sense of their appraisal and engagement with services. The data analysis resulted in four themes: Personal Reflections on Systemic Failure; Collective Concern and Blame; Decision Making Influencers and Rebuilding Knowledge and Trust. This analysis conveys distrust in the Irish Cervical Screening programme, feelings of anger, and a sense of neglect from the services. Irish women now place their trust in each other, the experience of their friends, families, their local GP. We discuss these finding to explore how Irish women have reinterpreted the narrative over the screening test in Ireland, and the potential to decrease concern around the topic by incorporating this experience into official narratives. This scandal heightened existing distrust and concern for the quality of womens screening services, and therefore has global relevance which can be applied to screening services more generally.

Matching journals

1
Health Expectations
Wiley · based on 12 published papers
#1
282× avg
2
PLOS ONE
Public Library of Science (PLoS) · based on 1737 published papers
Top 33%
14.5%
3
BMJ Open
BMJ · based on 553 published papers
Top 10%
2.9× avg
4
PLOS Global Public Health
Public Library of Science (PLoS) · based on 287 published papers
Top 6%
5.4× avg
5
BMC Public Health
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 148 published papers
Top 2%
8.8× avg
6
eLife
eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd · based on 262 published papers
Top 6%
3.1× avg
7
Sexually Transmitted Infections
BMJ · based on 20 published papers
Top 0.6%
28× avg
8
Preventive Medicine
Elsevier BV · based on 11 published papers
#1
59× avg
9
PLOS Digital Health
Public Library of Science (PLoS) · based on 88 published papers
Top 5%
4.9× avg
10
International Journal of Epidemiology
Oxford University Press (OUP) · based on 65 published papers
Top 4%
5.8× avg
11
Archives of Clinical and Biomedical Research
Fortune Journals · based on 18 published papers
Top 0.4%
16× avg
12
JMIR Formative Research
JMIR Publications Inc. · based on 31 published papers
Top 3%
7.9× avg
13
European Journal of Human Genetics
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 25 published papers
Top 1%
17× avg
14
Journal of Medical Internet Research
JMIR Publications Inc. · based on 81 published papers
Top 10%
2.1× avg
15
Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 11 published papers
Top 0.6%
24× avg
16
BMJ Global Health
BMJ · based on 95 published papers
Top 10%
2.1× avg
17
British Journal of Cancer
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 22 published papers
Top 3%
5.8× avg
18
Scientific Reports
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 701 published papers
Top 82%
0.9%
19
BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 19 published papers
Top 2%
7.0× avg
20
BMC Cancer
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 21 published papers
Top 4%
5.0× avg
21
BMC Health Services Research
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 43 published papers
Top 4%
4.3× avg
22
Cancer Medicine
Wiley · based on 17 published papers
Top 3%
7.1× avg
23
BMC Medicine
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 155 published papers
Top 23%
0.7%
24
Vaccines
MDPI AG · based on 131 published papers
Top 6%
2.3× avg