Insecticidal roof barriers mounted on untreated bednets can be as effective against Anopheles gambiae s.l. as insecticidal bednets

Barrier bednets (BBnets), regular bednets with a vertical insecticidal panel to target mosquitoes above the bednet roof, where activity is highest, have the potential to improve existing Insecticidal Treated Bednets (ITNs), by reducing quantity of insecticide required per net, reducing the toxic risks to those using the net, thus increasing the range of insecticides to choose from. We evaluated performance of different BBnet variants based on the PermaNet 3 (i.e., P3 BBnets with pyrethroid and piperonyl butoxide (PBO) on the roof or barrier; pyrethroid alone on the side walls) in room-scale bioassays, simultaneously video-recorded to track mosquitoes. Experimental results showed the longitudinal P3 barrier (P3L) to be highly effective: P3+P3L were consistently though not significantly more effective than the reference P3 bednet while performance of Ut+P3L was comparable to the reference P3. Comparing contact duration at the treated sections of each variant, the Ut+P3L accumulated 1273 contacts with 1374 seconds duration, all on the barrier, greatly exceeding the 792 seconds duration, from 8049 contacts, accumulated across the entire surface of the PermaNet 3 reference bednet. The BBnets potential to augment existing bednets and enhance their performance is considered.