Improving the Virtual Trichrome Assessment through Bridge Category Models

Non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) is a liver disease characterized by excessive lipid accumulation and disease progression is typically assessed through inspection of a Trichrome stain for Fibrosis staging. As the public health burden of NASH worsens due to evolving lifestyle habits, pathology laboratory resources will become increasingly strained due to rising demand for specialized stains. Virtual staining processes, computational methods which can synthesize the application of chemical staining reagents, can potentially provide resource savings by obviating the need to acquire specialized stains. Virtual staining technologies are assessed by comparing virtual and real tissue stains for their realism and ability to stage. However, these assessment methods are rife with statistical mistreatment of observed phenomena that are difficult to account for. Bridge category ratings represent a phenomenon where a pathologist may assign two adjacent stages simultaneously, which may bias and/or reduce the power of research findings. Such stage assignments were frequently reported in a large-scale assessment of Virtual Trichrome technologies yet were unaccounted for since no statistical adjustment procedures existed. In this work, we provide an updated assessment of Virtual Trichrome technologies using Bridge Category Models, which account for these bridge ratings. We report that two of four pathologists tended to assign lower Fibrosis stages to virtually stained tissue while the other two pathologists assigned similar stages. These research findings differ when bridge ratings are not accounted for. While promising, these results indicate further room for algorithmic finetuning of Virtual Trichrome technologies.