The role of synovial T-cell infiltration following knee joint injury in symptoms and progression to osteoarthritis

ObjectivesIdentification of osteoarthritis(OA)-specific synovial inflammatory pathways, and when in the clinical course they are active, is critical for their utility as therapeutic targets. We directly compared the mononuclear inflammatory/immune-cell responses following joint injury that does and does-not lead to OA, to define bona-fide OA-associated cellular events. MethodsWe undertook detailed temporal flow-cytometric and mRNA expression analysis in mice after sham or medial-meniscal-destiblization (DMM) surgery. We compared this with patients with meniscal injury and OA, and evaluated the role of synovial monocytes/macrophages versus lymphocytes in catabolic metalloproteinase secrection in vitro. We determined the effect of transient acute or delayed systemic T-cell depletion on DMM-induced OA pathology. ResultsOA-inducing/DMM and non-OA-inducing/Sham surgery had identical synovial monocyte/macrophage number, activation and polarization. The number and activation of synovial (not splenic or peripheral-blood) CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes was increased from 1-day after DMM versus Sham, and showed a persistent cyclical elevation throughout OA onset and progression. There was a temporal imbalance in synovial Th17/Treg and Th1/Th2 lymphocytes during DMM-induced OA initiation and progression. We confirmed early post-injury and late-OA CD3/CD8 T-cell responses in synovial tissues from patients, identified an association between CD8 and early post-injury symptoms, and defined a significant role for CD3+T-cells in synovial metalloproteinase secretion. Anti-CD3 cell-depletion studies in mice confirmed a key role for the earliest post-injury T-cell response in long-term OA pathology. ConclusionsWe identify a hitherto unappreciated pathophysiological role of acute T-cell activation after joint injury in long-term post-traumatic OA risk, providing a novel diagnostic and therapeutic target. Key MessagesO_ST_ABSWhat is already known about this subject?C_ST_ABSThe presence of synovitis/joint-inflammation increases the risk not only of osteoarthritis (OA) progression but incident disease. While numerous inflammatory effectors including macrophages and lymphocytes have been identified in OA, their disease-specificity, temporal regulation, and association with risk of pathology onset and progression is lacking. How does this study add?By directly comparing the mononuclear inflammatory/immune-cell responses following significant joint injury that does (medial-meniscal-destabilization; DMM) and does-not (Sham-surgery) lead to OA in mice, we have defined bona-fide OA-associated cellular events. There was no difference in synovial or systemic monocyte/macrophage cell number, activation or polarization between DMM and Sham, both showing a successful wound-healing response. In contrast, increases in number and activation of synovial Th1- and Th17-CD4, and CD8 T-cells in DMM compared with Sham occurred within the first 3 days, and while recurring cyclically through subsequent disease onset, depletion studies indicated this initial influx was key to long-term ptOA risk. How might this impact on clinical practice of future developments?Acute increases in synovial T-cells following jont injury may be both a novel marker of OA risk, and a target to reduce long term structural damage.